November 17, 2026
Navecar

Auto Financing

Auto Loan Refinancing: A Lower Payment Can Hide a Higher Remaining Cost

A worked $18,000 example compares keeping a loan with refinancing for 36 or 60 months, including a $300 fee paid in cash.

By Navecar Editorial2 min read
Black SUV parked outside a vehicle dealership
Erik Mclean / Pexels · Image source · Pexels License

Refinancing replaces your existing auto loan with a new one. The useful comparison is the cost still ahead under each option, including fees and any penalty for paying off the original agreement.

The CFPB explains that prepayment penalties depend on the contract and state law. Refinancing pays the old loan in full, so check that clause before treating a lower quoted rate as a saving.

Compare the same balance first

Consider a hypothetical $18,000 payoff balance. Keeping the current loan means 36 equal monthly payments at a fixed 10% nominal annual interest rate. Two replacement loans use 6%: one for 36 months and another for 60. Assume a $300 refinancing fee paid separately in cash.

Advertisement

Calculations divide each annual interest rate by 12 and use monthly amortization with payments at month-end. They include principal and interest, plus the stated cash fee where applicable. They exclude other charges, penalties, late payments and daily-interest adjustments. These are examples, not available offers or approval estimates.

OptionMonthly paymentFuture payments plus stated fee
Keep 10%, 36 months$580.81$20,909.14
Refinance 6%, 36 months$547.59$20,013.42
Refinance 6%, 60 months$347.99$21,179.43

Totals use unrounded payments; actual installment rounding can change the final payment.

The extended term changes the outcome

The 36-month replacement saves about $895.72 after the $300 fee. Extending to 60 months creates a much larger monthly reduction, but costs about $270.29 more than keeping the original schedule under these assumptions.

The smaller monthly commitment may matter to a household managing cash flow. It should still be identified as a payment reduction with a longer repayment period, rather than automatically described as a reduction in total cost.

Money already paid on the original loan is not added again to either future-cost column. For this decision, keep those past payments separate from the balance and costs that remain.

Request the documents needed for a real comparison

Obtain a dated payoff quote from the existing lender, the new loan’s amount financed, term, fees, interest rate and APR, and any prepayment conditions. APR includes applicable credit fees; the interest inputs used in this arithmetic are not a complete APR comparison.

Check whether fees are paid in cash or added to the new principal. If they are financed, recalculate the payment and total. Finally, confirm when the original lender receives payoff and keep its account-closure record. A refinance application or approval notice alone does not demonstrate that the old obligation has been settled.

Sources

Consumer Financial Protection Bureau

Advertisement

External advertiser content

Visit advertiser